I thought fathers came with answers. It took me years to realize he had never been a father before.

Open on YouTube ↗

Lyrics

Verse 1

When I was seven I followed you everywhere
Two little shoes behind your bigger ones
You knew which roads would take us home
You knew what every broken thing had done

I thought you knew the names of every star
Why thunder came and where the daylight went
And when you didn't have an answer
You made one up
And I believed it then

Chorus

You were older, you were taller
You were supposed to know the way
I thought fathers came with answers
For whatever came that day

I never thought you might be guessing
I never thought you could be unsure

You'd never had a boy like me
You'd never been a father before

Verse 2

At seventeen I stopped believing you
I found a lock and called the room my own
You said I had to be back by midnight
I said you didn't know me anymore

We learned to talk through closing doors
You learned that I could leave them closed
I'd never been seventeen before
You'd never had a seventeen-year-old

Chorus

You were older, you were calmer
You were supposed to know the way
I thought fathers had the answers
For whatever came that day

I never thought you might be guessing
Which things to hold and which to lose

You'd never had a boy like me
You'd never been a father before

Bridge

I'm getting close to the age you were
When I thought you knew everything
Maybe someone will ask me something
Like I'm supposed to know for sure
And maybe I'll answer like I know

Chorus

You're still older, I'm still younger
But that doesn't mean the same
I used to think you had a map
Now I know you learned the way

Every year I became somebody
You had never met before

You'd never had a son this age
You'd never been a father before

Final Chorus

I'll be older, I'll be taller
I'll be supposed to know the way
Maybe he'll think I have the answers
For whatever comes that day

Every year he'll become somebody
I've never met before
I'll have to learn him as he grows
I've never been a father before

Outro

I learned from you
I will learn from him
I just didn't know
That you were learning too.